Can a Landlord Require Pet Insurance: Your Questions Answered
Bringing a pet into a new rental situation can come with its own set of questions. One of the most common is about pet insurance… do you need it? Or an even better question, can a landlord require pet insurance? This seems like some pretty good questions to get answered before you decide and sign on the dotted line with a new rental agreement.
Our Atlanta area property management requires that we be experts on these types of things. It’s important to not only make sure rental agreements are legal and included everything they should for all kinds of situations, but also it’s certainly a good idea to make sure all of this is communicated clearly. Landlords, owners, and especially renters need to have all of this info spelled out clearly. Let’s dive into pet insurance and what the requirements are for rental units.
Table of Contents
- Can a Landlord Require Pet Insurance?
- Your Pet-Related Rights
- For Landlords and Owners: Hire BMG to Help You
Can a Landlord Require Pet Insurance

The short answer to can a landlord require pet insurance is yes. There’s no law that requires it, but it’s legal to put a “renters insurance with pet coverage” clause into the lease. This is similar to how some landlords require regular renters insurance in general. The main thing is whether they make it clear in the lease agreement.
There are a lot of reasons a landlord might decide to require pet insurance. It can help cover repairs if a dog scratches up the hardwood or a cat shreds the carpet. It can also protect the renter if someone gets injured by a tenant’s pet on your property. The cost for tenants is usually reasonable, especially compared to the potential costs of a big claim. Plus, it can make landlords more comfortable saying YES to pets in the first place, which opens the property up to more potential renters.
Your Pet-Related Rights

- Service and support animals – Renters have the right to keep service animals and emotional support animals even in properties that have a “no pets” policy. These animals are protected under federal laws like the Fair Housing Act, and landlords cannot charge extra fees for them. However, landlords can ask for proper documentation in the case of an emotional support animal. If a tenant has a disability that requires the use of a service or support animal, landlords are required to make reasonable accommodations.
- Limits on pet deposits and fees – Hey, places and state laws can vary some. In some rentals, there are restrictions on how much a landlord can charge for pet deposits or fees. While this varies by location, many states do not allow pet fees to be nonrefundable, for example. So look into your local laws to see that the lease agreement terms are aligned with what your state requires.
- Right to a safe and humane environment – Even in rentals that allow pets, landlords still have to maintain safe, habitable conditions for both the tenant and their animal. That means fixing hazards that could harm the pet and making sure that the property is free from dangerous conditions.
- Protection from discriminatory pet policies – Landlords can set reasonable rules, but they cannot selectively enforce pet restrictions against certain tenants in a way that could be considered discriminatory. Rules have to be applied equally to all renters in similar situations.
For Landlords and Owners: Hire BMG to Help You
Before you sign any policy or start renting somewhere, if you happen to have a pet, take a moment to ask the right questions. It goes beyond can a landlord require pet insurance. Check what all the policies are in the rental agreement and what your rights are… ask about breed or animal restrictions and generally get clear on everything you need to know. And if your the landlord or owner and all this feels like a lot to figure out on your own (do you even have landlord insurance?), well than that’s where we come in as the experts on those sorts of things.
At Bay Property Management Group, we make it easy to understand lease terms and crafting something that is legal and fair for everyone… all from the very beginning. Contact us today to learn more about how we can help. We provide expert property management services in Decatur and Atlanta areas. as well as Texas, Maryland, Massachusetts, Virginia, and many other locations.